The Sweetest Secret: Decadent Chocolate Pizzelle Recipe

Dec 16, 2022 | Kitchen Gadgets, Recipes

Calling all Cookie Lovers, meet decadent chocolate pizzelles. With a rich, chocolatey flavor and a crispy texture, this pizzelle recipe will be the perfect treat for any chocoholic. These are amazing Christmas cookies! Plus our top pizzelle irons. Check out this chocolate pizzelle recipe.

It’s Christmas time, meaning it’s time to pull out the pizzelle iron. We have a new pizzelle cookie we had to whisk together. Make these chocolate pizzelle today. These will become your favorite Christmas cookies.

Below, check out our FAQs and our Top Picks for pizzelle irons.

Chocolate Pizzelles


3 large eggs

3/4 cup sugar

2 teaspoons baking powder

1/2 cup butter (melted and cooled)

1 3/4 cups all-purpose flour

3 tablespoons cocoa

3 tablespoons sugar


  1. Melt butter (set aside)
  2. Beat eggs and sugar together (2-3 mins.) until a light yellow color
  3. Add melted butter and beat until blended.
  4. In a separate mixing bowl, sift together 1 cup of the flour, and baking powder. Whisk the cocoa powder, sugar, sifted flour, and baking soda together.
  5. Now combine the dry ingredients with the wet ingredients.
  6. Fold together until just blended.
  7. Add the remaining flour and fold again until just incorporated
  8. Preheat pizzelle iron
  9. Place approximately 2 tablespoons of the batter on the center of the pattern
  10. Bake for about 1:15-2 minutes.
  11. Remove and cool
  12. Repeat until the pizzelle batter is done.
  13. Enjoy your new favorite e Italian cookie

Our Favorite Pizzelle Irons

Why We Love It

Discover the timeless tradition of Italian baking with VillaWare pizzelle maker. This unique product is a must-have for any serious baker! It features Xylan non-stick grids and an automatic thermostat with a “ready” light to ensure your waffle-like cookies are perfectly cooked every time. The Steam Guard feature keeps your hands protected, while the cord wrap allows for convenient storage. The set even includes instructions and recipes to help you make delicious treats!

Why We Love It

Are you longing for a taste of Italy without having to leave your home? Treat yourself and your family to delicious, authentic Italian pizzelles with Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic! This easy-to-use device quickly bakes perfect pizzelles that are crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside. Whether it’s your weekly dinner or an extra special occasion, everyone will love Palmer Pizzelle Maker’s classic recipe. Plus, its nonstick cooking surface makes cleanup easy.

Why We Love It

Take your Italian cooking to the next level with the CucinaPro pizzelle maker! Our state-of-the-art press will help you make perfect pizzelles every time. Equipped with extra-thick baking plates, this machine ensures even heating and an evenly cooked product. The makers also include a range of recipes, so you can experiment with different flavours and combinations.

So gather your friends and family and get ready to enjoy some delicious Italian cookies. Buon appetito!

Do You Have Pizzelle Questions? We’ve Got Answers!

Making pizzelles can be a little intimidating if you’ve never done it before.

But don’t worry, we’re here to help. We’ve compiled a list of the most frequently asked questions about these amazing machines so that you can make the perfect batch of pizzelles every time.

Ready to get started? Here are the most frequently asked questions to help you make the perfect pizzelle today!

A pizzelle cookie is a traditional Italian dessert that has been around for centuries. It is a thin, flat cookie made from flour, sugar, eggs, butter or olive oil, and flavorings such as anise or vanilla. The dough is pressed into a special pizzelle iron and lightly cooked on both sides to give it its signature slightly crisp texture.

Pizzelle cookies can be served plain or with various toppings including powdered sugar, jam, Nutella, fruit preserves or even chocolate chips. They are especially popular during the holidays and can often be found in Italian bakeries and specialty stores. Pizzelles make for the perfect accompaniment to coffee or tea and are sure to please everyone with their delicious taste and delightful crunch.

Where do pizzelles come from?

Pizzelle are a traditional Italian cookie, originating in the Abruzzo region of Italy. They were originally made in the form of two thin waffles that were pressed together with a design in the center. The design was meant to represent the irons used to make them, which were heated over an open fire and then placed between two metal plates to create the cookies.

Pizzelles are usually flavoured with anise or vanilla extract and often dipped in chocolate or sprinkled with sugar. Today, pizzelles are still popular in Italy as well as other countries around the world. They can be found in many different shapes and sizes, from round to rectangular or even star-shaped. While some recipes are more intricate than others, all pizzelles have one thing in common – they’re delicious!

What consistency should pizzelle batter be?

Pizzelle batter should be a medium-thick consistency, similar to that of a crepe batter. It should not be too thin like a pancake batter or too thick like cake batter. The correct consistency will allow the pizzelle to bake evenly and crisp up properly.

To achieve the right texture, use an electric mixer to combine the wet ingredients until they are smooth, then add the dry ingredients slowly, one at a time. Make sure all of the dry ingredients are fully incorporated before pouring the batter into your pizzelle iron. If necessary, you can adjust the consistency by adding more liquid if it is too thick or more flour if it is too thin. With this method, you can ensure that you have a perfect batter every time for perfect pizzelles!

Does chocolate pizzelle batter differ from the original pizelle batter?

The two batters are quite similar but there are some differences. The main difference is the addition of chocolate to the chocolate pizzelle batter. This makes the batter smoother and richer, giving it a more intense flavor. The original pizelle batter is usually made with a combination of flour, sugar, eggs, butter or oil, and vanilla extract or anise for flavoring.

The chocolate pizzelle batter, on the other hand, adds cocoa powder to the mix for a deep chocolaty taste. Other ingredients may also be added like hazelnuts or almonds for texture and flavor enhancement. In general, both batters can be used interchangeably but depending on your preference you may prefer one over the other.

Why are my pizzelles not crispy?

Pizzelles are a traditional Italian cookie that are usually light and crispy. However, if your pizzelles are not turning out as crispy as you would like, there could be a few reasons why. One reason is that the batter may have been too thick or too thin; the ideal consistency should be somewhere in between.

Another possible culprit is the temperature of your iron; if it’s too hot, the outside of the pizzelle will burn before the inside can cook through, resulting in an uncrispy texture. Finally, overbaking can also make pizzelles less crispy; try to remove them from the iron after just a few seconds so they don’t overcook.

With a little tweaking with ingredients and technique, you should be able to get perfectly crisp and delicious pizzelles every time!

How long do pizzelles stay good for?

Pizzelles are a delicious Italian cookie that can be enjoyed all year round. They are made with flour, eggs, sugar, butter or oil and flavoring such as anise or vanilla. These cookies are usually thin and crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. When it comes to how long they stay good for, it depends on how they are stored. If you keep them in an airtight container at room temperature, they should last around two weeks. In the refrigerator, they will stay fresh for up to two months. If you want to store your pizzelles for an even longer period of time, freezing them is your best bet – frozen pizzelles will remain tasty for up to three months! Enjoy these delicious cookies while they last!

What else can you make with a pizzelle maker?

A pizzelle maker is a great tool for cooking delicious Italian cookies. However, it can do much more than just make pizzelles. You can use the pizzelle maker to create waffles, crepes, and even pancakes. With the different designs available in the market, you can also make decorative shapes such as flowers or stars. Furthermore, you can even use it to make savory dishes like quesadillas or grilled sandwiches. The possibilities are endless when it comes to what else you can make with a pizzelle maker. All you need is some creativity and imagination!

How do Italians eat pizzelles?

When it comes to eating pizzelles, Italians have their own unique way of doing it. The traditional way to eat them is to sprinkle them with powdered sugar and then break them into pieces. This allows for the flavors of the cookie to be fully appreciated, as the different layers of flavor are revealed.

Another popular way to enjoy pizzelles is by dipping them in a sweet syrup, such as honey or even Nutella. This method also helps bring out the sweetness of the cookie and enhances its texture and flavor. Italians also sometimes sandwich two pizzelles together with a layer of jam or nutella in between for an added bit of sweetness.

Pizzelles can be enjoyed any time of day, from breakfast to an after-dinner snack. No matter how you choose to eat your pizzelle, it’s sure to be a delicious treat!

Why do my pizzelle stick to the pizelle iron?

Pizzelle have a very delicate texture and can become quite fragile when cooked. Unfortunately, because of this fragility they can be prone to sticking to the pizzelle iron. The heat from the iron causes the pizzelle batter to melt and expand, creating a suction-like effect that makes them stick to the iron. To prevent this from happening, it’s important to use enough oil or butter in your pizzelle batter so that it is moist enough not to stick. It’s also helpful to lightly grease your pizzelle iron before using it with cooking spray or melted butter. Finally, make sure you cook your pizzelle for just the right amount of time; if they are overcooked they will become more likely to stick. With these tips in mind, making delicious crispy homemade pizzelles should be no trouble at all!

How long does it take to cook a pizzelle?

Cooking a pizzelle can take anywhere from 30 seconds to a few minutes, depending on the size of the pizzelle and the temperature of your pizzelle maker. Generally, if your pizzelle maker is pre-heated to 375 degrees Fahrenheit and you are using 4-5 inch diameter pizzelles, it will take about 30 seconds to cook each one. If you are using a slightly larger pizzelle or have your machine set at a lower temperature, it could take up to 2 minutes for each one. It’s best to check on them periodically so they don’t get overcooked. When done properly, the outside should be lightly golden with some brown spots and the inside should be chewy but cooked all the way through. Enjoy!

How do you clean your pizzelle maker?

When it comes to cleaning your pizzelle maker, the most important thing is to make sure that you do it correctly. The best way to begin is by unplugging the pizzelle maker and allowing it to cool down completely. Once it has cooled down, use a damp cloth or sponge to wipe down both the outside and inside of the pizzelle maker. Make sure you pay extra attention around any of the creases and seams, as these are areas where food particles may be hiding. You can then use a soft bristled brush to remove any stubborn dirt particles from the iron griddle. Finally, give your pizzelle maker a good rinse with warm water before drying it off with a clean dish towel or microfiber cloth. This will help ensure that no food particles remain on your pizzelle maker after each use.

Maybe you never made pizzelles, but don’t let that stop you from trying! This Christmas cookie recipe is easy. Make a batch today,  you will not regret learning or eating these crispy cookies. You will make them every year!

VillaWare Prego Nonstick Pizzelle Baker

Palmer Pizzelle Maker Classic

Cucina Pro Pizzelle Baker

Related Posts